Tag Archives: Joseph

Hashem’s Mathematical Justice

In this week’s parasha, Vayeshev, we read about the unfortunate sale of Joseph. Two big questions come up: First, why did Jacob deserve the cruel experience of not only losing his beloved son, but then also being tricked by his other sons? Second, why did Joseph deserve to be sold into slavery and spend a dozen years in prison? We know that God always acts justly, middah k’neged middah, “measure for measure”, so why did these two righteous figures deserve such tribulations?

The Zohar (I, 185b) on this week’s parasha points out some incredible parallels between what Jacob’s sons did to him, and what Jacob did to his father Isaac. Jacob had slaughtered some goats, was dressed up in “goat skins”, and presented his father with delicious goat meat in order to trick his father into a blessing. Jacob’s sons did the same in slaughtering a goat and dipping Joseph’s tunic in its blood to trick their father. Isaac had asked Jacob “Are you my son Esau, or not?” (ha’atah ze bni Esav im lo?) and Jacob’s sons similarly told him “Do you recognize this tunic to be your son’s, or not?” (haker na haktonet binkha im lo?) The result was that Isaac experienced a “great terror” (charadah gedolah), just as Jacob did. Thus, the Zohar says, what Jacob’s sons put him through is precisely what he had put his own father through! And this all came from God, who is medakdek when it comes to tzadikim: He is perfectly, mathematically, precise in His justice, measure for measure.

We can take this teaching in the Zohar one step further. We find that after Jacob tricked Esau, the latter was so angry he resolved to kill Jacob, which prompted Rebecca to send Jacob to her uncle in Haran. Although there are different opinions as to how long it took him to get to Haran, the pshat of the Torah is that he went to Haran immediately and spent twenty years with Lavan (Genesis 31:38). After he came back to the Holy Land, he reunited with his father Isaac whom he hadn’t seen for at least twenty years (Genesis 35:27). In the case of Joseph, the Torah tells us he was seventeen when he was sold (Genesis 37:2), and thirty when he became viceroy of Egypt (Genesis 41:46). There was then a seven-year period of plenty—until Joseph turned 37 years old—followed by the start of the famine, during which time Jacob was reunited with Joseph. Doing the math, we find that Jacob and Joseph were also separated for just over twenty years. Again, God’s retribution is exact!

Let’s turn to Joseph: why did he have to be sold into servitude and spend twelve years in an Egyptian prison? We read that he was an excellent servant in the house of Potiphar, and was put in charge of all of Potiphar’s affairs (Genesis 39:3). He lived very well there, until Potiphar’s wife tried to seduce him incessantly. When he kept refusing, she put in a false report of sexual assault, leading to Joseph’s arrest and imprisonment. This is not a coincidence either, for the parasha begins by telling us that Joseph would bring “bad reports” about his brothers to his father (Genesis 37:2). Just as Joseph made false reports about his siblings, Potiphar’s wife made a false report about Joseph! The result was twelve years in prison, and it is easy to suggest why specifically twelve since, after all, Joseph had a total of twelve siblings (including Dinah). The Midrash (Beresheet Rabbah 84:7) further emphasizes God’s exacting punishment:

“Joseph brought evil report of them to their father” – what did he say? Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yehuda, and Rabbi Shimon [taught]: Rabbi Meir says [that Joseph would report]: “Your sons are suspected of eating the limb of a living animal.” Rabbi Shimon says: “They are directing their gaze at the girls of the land.” Rabbi Yehuda says: “They are demeaning the sons of the maidservants [Bilhah and Zilpah] and calling them slaves.”

Rabbi Yehuda bar Simon said: He was punished for all three of them, for “Balances and scales of justice are Hashem’s…” (Proverbs 16:11) The Holy One, blessed be He, said to him: “You said: ‘Your sons are suspected of eating the limb of a living animal.’ As you live, even at their time of corruption, they will slaughter and only then will they eat [as it is written:] ‘and slaughtered a goat.’ (Genesis 37:31) You said: ‘They are demeaning the sons of the maidservants and calling them slaves.’ [And so,] ‘Joseph was sold as a slave.’ (Psalms 105:17) You said: ‘They are directing their gaze at the girls of the land.’ As you live, I will incite the same against you [as it is written,] ‘His master’s wife cast her eyes [upon Joseph, and she said: Lie with me.]’” (Genesis 39:7)

‘Joseph Makes Himself Known to His Brethren’ by Gustav Doré

One thing that we learn from this is that the brothers of Joseph were not all that wrong in being suspicious of him, and perhaps even wanting to rid of him. He did have a dangerously large ego, and we go on to read in the Torah how Joseph consolidated more and more power in Egypt, eventually enslaving the entire Egyptian populace (Genesis 47). It isn’t surprising that the angry and subdued Egyptians later turned the tables and enslaved the Israelites! Because of this need to dominate, the Zohar (I, 200a) says Joseph was not given his own flag among the Tribes. The Zohar points out there was no degel machane Yosef, but only a degel machane Ephraim. The flag of Joseph was replaced with the flag of his son, serving as something of a “demotion” due to Joseph’s desire for superiority. The Talmud (Berakhot 55a), meanwhile, points out that Joseph was first to die among his brothers for similar reasons of ego.

Now, all of this is not to take away from Joseph’s righteousness. After all, he is called Yosef haTzadik, the epitome of righteousness, and embodied sexual purity, restraint, and great wisdom. Nonetheless, no one is perfect, and the Torah highlights the flaws of its heroes so that we can learn from them. The Torah was given to guide us in refining ourselves and becoming better people; to teach us that God is merciful and longsuffering, giving us many opportunities to repent and rectify, even across multiple lives and eras.

In fact, Joseph was reincarnated in his descendant Joshua, the humble servant of Moses (see Sefer Gilgulei Neshamot, Letter Mem). Both Joseph and Joshua are described in the Torah as being filled with a Godly spirit, and both died at the exact same age of 110 (see Genesis 50:26 and Joshua 24:29). Joseph was the reason the brothers came down to Egypt in the first place and ended up staying there “in exile” for centuries, so fittingly it was Joshua that brought the Children of Israel back into the Holy Land. Humble Joshua—who spent the first part of his life enslaved to the Egyptians—was the rectification for haughty Joseph. And the final incarnation of that soul is in Mashiach ben Yosef (Sefer Gilgulei Neshamot, Letter Pei), to once more bring all the Children of Israel back to the Holy Land at the End of Days, and usher in a better world for all mankind.

Shabbat Shalom and Happy Chanukah!

Chanukah Learning Resources:

Chanukah’s Electrifying Secret (Video)
Chanukah & the Light of Creation (Video)
Did the Jews Really Defeat the Greeks?
When Jews and Greeks Were Brothers
Death of Hellenism, Then and Now
Rabbi Akiva and the Maccabees
Where in the Torah is Chanukah?

The Tribe of Ephraim

Who was the Biblical Ephraim and why did he merit to become the most powerful tribe in ancient Israel? Find out in this class as we take a journey through Ephraim’s past, present, and future. Along the way, we uncover the fascinating stories of the great Ephraimite Judges and Kings of the Holy Land (including Joshua, Deborah, and Samuel) and explore who might be the descendants of the Ephraimites today. Plus: Why does the Tanakh connect Ephraim to Amalek? Is the Messiah supposed to be a Judean or an Ephraimite (or both)? And has the prophecy of Ezekiel 37 been fulfilled in our days?

See also ‘The Truth About the Lost Tribes of Israel’.
For more on the spiritual significance of iron, see ‘Israel and the Iron Age’.

Jonah’s Secret Link to Yom Kippur

‘Jonah Preaching to the Ninevites’ by Gustav Doré

One of the great highlights of Yom Kippur is the unique afternoon Haftarah reading of the Book of Jonah. Recall that Yonah is tasked by God to go to the Assyrian metropolis of Nineveh and preach to them to repent, lest they be destroyed. Yonah fails to carry out his mission at first and instead goes out to sea. When a storm rages, he knows it is his fault and tells the sailors to throw him overboard. The storm is calmed, while Yonah is swallowed up by a “big fish”.

After three days of reflection in the belly of the beast, Yonah is vomited ashore and goes off to fulfil God’s mission. Nineveh hears his call and repents wholeheartedly, averting their fate. Yonah is upset by this, explaining that he knew the Ninevites would repent, and that’s why he didn’t want to deliver the message (4:1-2). Presumably, it would make the stiff-necked Jews look bad, since the Jews rarely listened to their own prophets! God concludes the book with a message that He cares deeply about all of His creations, including the 120,000+ people in Nineveh, and even the animals there (4:11). What does any of this have to do with Yom Kippur?

The simplest answer is that we read Yonah because it mentions many themes of the High Holiday season. First of all, Yonah gives the Ninevites forty days to repent or else the city would be overturned (3:4), just as we have Forty Days of Repentance between Rosh Chodesh Elul and Yom Kippur. (Based on this, one could reason that Yonah likely arrived in Nineveh on Rosh Chodesh Elul and the city was spared on Yom Kippur.) The Ninevites then proclaimed a fast (3:5), just as we fast on Yom Kippur. After this, Yonah leaves town and makes a sukkah for himself in the wilderness (4:5), just as we head right into Sukkot after Yom Kippur. This seems like enough to justify the selection of Yonah for the holiday reading. But I always felt like there must be more.

A few big questions jumped out at me when reading the story: Why is it that when Yonah is out at sea and the storm begins, he decides to go take a nap while the sailors are panicking (1:5)? How could he even think of sleeping? And when the sailors then question him about the storm, he tells them to throw him overboard to quell it (1:12). Why didn’t Yonah just jump overboard himself? Why make the sailors throw him out? Finally, we might expect that these rough sailors wouldn’t care much about a passing Hebrew among them, and would gladly throw him out to spare their lives. Instead, we read that the sailors refused to do so, and instead “the men rowed hard to regain the shore, but they could not, for the sea was growing more and more stormy about them.” (1:13)

The sailors eventually decide they have no choice but to throw Yonah overboard, but before doing so they pray to God wholeheartedly: “Oh, please, Hashem, do not let us perish on account of this man’s life. Do not hold us guilty of killing an innocent person!” (1:14) Why are these gentile sailors so deeply concerned about a random Hebrew that hitched a ride with them? Why are they suddenly so faithful and fearful of the God of Israel? And their faith in Hashem didn’t stop with the subduing of the storm. The chapter ends saying “The men feared God greatly; they offered a sacrifice to God and they made vows.” (1:16) What are these “vows”? The Zohar (II, 230b) says they all converted to Judaism and became tzadikim and talmidei chakhamim!

What’s going on?

Joseph Returns

I believe we can solve this mystery by recalling an ancient tradition that the Sale of Joseph took place on the tenth of Tishrei—what would later become Yom Kippur. This tradition goes all the way back to Second Temple times, and is even recorded in the Book of Jubilees (34:10-18). Jubilees go so far as to say that Jacob actually commemorated Joseph’s yahrzeit every year on the tenth of Tishrei. Centuries later, when God forgave Israel for the sin of the Golden Calf at Sinai—thus officially giving rise to Yom Kippur—He also officially forgave the Sons of Israel for the Sale of Joseph. What the ten sons had done was throw their brother Joseph “overboard” into an empty pit that didn’t even have a drop of water (Genesis 37:24). They abandoned the innocent soul, and he was later picked up and enslaved by Midianites who sold him to Ishmaelites down to Egypt. (See ‘Was Joseph Really Sold By His Brothers?’ in Volume One of Garments of Light.) When was the sin of the brothers rectified? It is quite possible that it was rectified on that ship with Yonah:

The Arizal tells us that Yonah had a spark of the soul of Yosef (and of the future Mashiach ben Yosef, too, see Sha’ar haGilgulim, Ch. 32). And so, a great storm surges and Yonah—the Joseph that he is—goes to sleep to dream divine dreams. When he is awakened, he knows the (ten?) sailors are reincarnations of his old brothers. So, he tells them that if they want to be spared, they must throw him overboard (just like old times). But the sailors know deep in their souls that they have a tikkun to make, and they staunchly refuse. When their fiercest efforts to battle the storm fail, they resort to sincere teshuva and prayer. Previously, they threw their brother into a pit “with no water”, and now they throw him right into the raging waters. The sea is immediately calmed. Then, of all things, Yonah is miraculously saved by a big fish.

Recall that the fish is symbolic of Joseph, whom our Sages (in Bava Metzia 84a) compared to a fish that is impervious to the evil eye. (Some even see the two “lucky” fish of Pisces as Joseph’s sons Ephraim and Menashe!) And Joseph’s greatest descendant (who also carried a spark of his soul) was Yehoshua bin Nun, literally “son of a fish” (nun means “fish” in Aramaic). In fact, the nun root is thought to be the etymology for Nineveh.

Another interesting parallel: the language used to describe the calming of the sea when Yonah was thrown overboard is strangely va’ya’amod hayam, literally “the sea stood”. This is a clear allusion to the standing walls of the Splitting of the Sea which, according to the Midrash, split and stood in the merit of Joseph! (Beresheet Rabbah 87:8). This only further points to Yonah being Yosef reincarnated.

Ultimately, the repentant sailors go on to convert to Judaism and become great tzadikim in their own right. Their rectification is complete; the brothers are perfectly redeemed. And this is the whole point of Yom Kippur after all: the redemption of the children of Israel. May we merit to see the Final Redemption this year.

Gmar Chatima Tova and Chag Sameach!

Yom Kippur & Sukkot Learning Resources:

The Kabbalah of Yom Kippur (Video)
How the Priestly Garments Atoned for the People
Ushpizin & Anti-Ushpizin
Medicinal Properties of Arba Minim
Russia, Iran, and Gog u’Magog (Video)